
In this first installment of Agree to Disagree, wise sage and Daily Snooze pal Jim Curley helps us understand and appreciate the latest release from our favorite band of the moment: Spoon.
NICK: Hey Jim. On tap for our first online conversation is the latest release from indie rock quartet Spoon, titled Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga, which debuted at #10 a few weeks back on the Billboard charts, selling around 40,000 copies. It's ironic that for our first installment of Agree to Disagree we probably won't clash all that much, because I can't see how anyone could avoid falling prey to the rhythm and soul on this album. Like its predecessor, Gimme Fiction, Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga provides listeners with the perfect summer soundtrack. Containing ten lean and slender tracks and clocking in at just under 37 minutes, the group seems to be playing to their reputation as minimalists.
But this album continues a trend of expanding production values that began with the release of Girls Can Tell and the group's move to Merge Records in 2000. Longtime producer Michael McCarthy does Gimme Fiction one better and turns singer/songwriter Britt Daniels' voice into its own beat-machine. His delivery is so catchy and effective on "You Got Yr Cherry Bomb" that even the addition of horns takes a backseat to his vocals. But nowhere is the heightened production value more obvious than on "The Ghost of You Lingers." While it may have been the track's stuttered drilling of piano chords that gave the album its name, it's the three different angles from which Daniels' vocals hit you that differentiates this song from any other on the album. To me, it is THE central track on Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga. The sonic landscape it creates blows me away. But feel free to disagree with me, Jim. I dare you.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JIM: Congratulations on a very clever, albeit useless, tactic to goad me into attacking a succinctly well-crafted, sometimes adventurous pop record from Spoon. As I find myself (by default?) in the infinitely harder position as rebutter, I’ll do my best to avoid redundancies throughout the review. But disclaimers aside, here is the inaugural, and likely more interesting, 2nd half to Agree to Disagree.
This fifth LP is a well-blended showcase of formulaic but ever charming minimalism, accentuated with robust pop arrangements by the Texas outfit Spoon. Evidently, they have continued to outgrow their minimalist cowboy boots on tracks like the new single “The Underdog” and “You Got Yr. Cherry Bomb”, with a horn section earnestly affirming Brit Daniel’s plea “Life can be so fair/ Let it go on and on” to downtrodden indie maidens everywhere. In the same vain is the anthem “The Underdog”, which finds Daniel preaching to the delusional over acoustic guitar crescendos and galvanized trumpets and horns.
Lyrical analysis is often a masturbatory exercise because of the subjective nature of songs. However, while Daniel seems despondent and paranoid in his often abstract musings, his delivery is anxiously hopeful, especially on the groove infused “Don’t You Evah.” Bassist Rob Pope’s hooks will have you feeling headier than Al Gore III driving down the San Diego Freeway.
This is an undeniable catchy album, which is no surprise coming from a band gifted with an ear for accessible, interesting pop music and a vocalist whose set of lungs sounds sterling in studio. Here the band’s deft excursions into new sonic territory are commendable. Spoon’s formula is viral, and only strengthens any compositional digressions they attempt. But like any junky stripped of his reason by such potent sonic opiates, I demand more from my addiction. There is nothing truly daring about these songs. Yes Nick, “The Ghost of You Lingers” is the explorative linchpin on Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga, and I’m disappointed in myself for not warming up to its spectral vocal layers and propulsive tension earlier. Does it neutralize filler like “Rhythm and Soul” or “Black Like Me”? Probably. Nothing on the record spans over four minutes, so boredom is virtually impossible. Regardless, with a musical canon as strong as Spoon’s, expectations and standards are the hurdles of the day, not their musical limitations and choices.
Ah, the age-old dilemma, keep going or change. Since Kill the Moonlight, these boys have been pondering that infinite question, with small and large tweaks to their subsequent releases. They never falter when endlessly trying to reconcile these two opposites, but when the line between them is shrunken past recognition, negotiation between each polar gets complicated. Sure it’s self-evident, but the progress or regression of this band is something to look forward to.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NICK: That’s a very nice little summary of the album, Jim. Any opportunity to use the word masturbatory is rare, so I respect its, um, insertion into your opinion. But frankly, I think that lyrical analysis is pretty integral when discussing a band that we both agree is one of the finest in the land. It’s taken me a while to digest the stylish utterances of Brit Daniel on this album, and I find myself a little disappointed. Daniel has always had a penchant for relating seemingly ultra-personal stories, detail by detail, to his audience, but on Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga, he’s getting a little too cute. If it weren’t for his pitch-perfect delivery, I might actually hold him to the same standards that I hold some of his colleagues, such as Jeff Tweedy of Wilco and Jim James of My Morning Jacket.
For example, in the dancers’ call to arms, “Rhythm and Soul”, Daniel encourages us to get our hands out of our back pockets and do some twisting and shouting. Then, in the middle of nowhere, we get this stanza: “Here comes the man / you saw in Kazan / he just picks in his cold / rhythm and soul.”
I mean, honestly, what the hell? And “Black Like Me” is just as bad. While even some grown women with teenage hearts might find his pseudo-earnestness endearing, I find it contrived, at best. Luckily, “Finer Feelings” is one of the finest and most coherent pop songs Spoon has ever written, and like you said, “The Underdog” is an amusing stab at the ignorant, perhaps directed at the Ignoramus-in-Chief, himself. I don’t know, it just sounds a little political to me. That’s all I got. Any last words?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JIM: Last words? Hmmm, let me count the ways you continue to overlook inherent problems with this disc.
Some new fodder for you and the myriad of readers who no doubt will stumble across “Agree to Disagree” to digest is these boys’ ability to translate songs in a live setting. Being in attendance for Spoon’s evening set at Lollapalooza Saturday, I was shocked to see the omission of “Underdog”, You Got Yr. Cherry Bomb”, and “The Ghost of You Lingers.” While they were short a horn section at Lolla, I still wonder how thin these tracks would have sounded. Their performance was compelling and tight, and much stronger than I expected. Which only leads me to further wonder, why the omissions?
Prior to the set, I believed we had a modern day Steely Dan on our hands. No disrespect to Steely, but I want to feel these songs live and Spoon’s Indian-giving tendency at the Chicago festival was disappointing. They met me halfway. “Don’t Make Me a Target” and “Don’t You Evah” had the audience rocking and grooving respectively, but the gems were still missing.
Enough concert talk and back to the lyrics. Some of this stuff seems like lazy free association. Metaphors and characters materialize like ghosts, and just as quickly disappear. You nailed it when talking about the line concerning a man from Kazan. I’m not even going to go through the whole album, because it is saturated with even more “what the fuck” lines.
But the music is catchy and Brit has a pretty voice. So what can I say…
Cockblockery aside, I’m bad at playing devil’s advocate and really enjoy this album. Ring the damn bell. This one is over. At the day’s end, Spoon’s fifth disc remains impregnable from any shit I tried to sling at it. Over and Out.